Take for instance, the Cubs former leadoff hitter Alfonso Soriano. Soriano is neither getting hits (.252 AVG) nor getting on base (.313 OBP) at the rate you would expect of a leadoff hitter. On top of that he has struck out 94 times and hasn't redeemed himself with a lot of stolen bases (7 SB). More striking, however, is that for his 18 homers, he only has 45 RBI to show. Cincinnati's Brandon Phillips--former leadoff hitter--has 67 RBI while touting three fewer home runs than Soriano. Couldn't the North-siders be getting much more offensive contribution from him lower in the order?
Well, after two and a half years the Cubs finally dropped Soriano in the order. Last night, while hitting sixth, Soriano came up with the bases loaded and belted a grand slam. Granted you can't judge success based on one at-bat, but if I were a Cubs fan I would be rejoicing about Soriano's new home in the order.
For all that, I think Soriano's case is a rare one. If a player has a rare combination of speed, discipline, and power, I can understand the interest in slotting him at the top. Here are a handful of leadoff hitters right now that don't have to live off infield base hits and Texas leaguers.
1. 2B Ian Kinsler (Texas): .242 AVG, .314 OBP , 22 SB, 23 HR, 60 RBI
-Kinsler is similar to Soriano in that he doesn't get on enough for a leadoff guy. However, he does steal a lot of bases and has managed to produce a lot of RBI.
2. OF Curtis Granderson (Detroit): .260 AVG, .344 OBP , 17 SB, 20 HR, 47 RBI
-Although he's losing RBI at the one-hole, his speed may be to hard to pass up in that role.
3. OF Nate McLouth (Atlanta): .259 AVG, .349 OBP, 15 SB, 15 HR, 52 RBI
-His penchant for not getting caught on the base-paths is nice to have at the top of the order.
4. Grady Sizemore (Cleveland): .230 AVG, .323 OBP, 9 SB, 14 HR, 51 RBI
-He's having a down year all around, so it's hard to judge.
5. SS Jimmy Rollins (Philadelphia): .236 AVG, .289 OBP, 17 SB, 10 HR, 46 RBI
-Hit 30 homers in 2007. Isn't doing much of anything this year.
Honorable Mention: Hanley Ramirez, Johnny Damon, and Brian Roberts
-Former leadoff hitters that all have plenty of pop in their bats.